Eleanor M. Kellon, VMD
The “whole food” claim is being used to market some feeds and supplements for horses, but what is a whole food and are these products really superior?
The term whole food is not currently regulated, so it can mean anything the company using it wants it to mean. “Whole food” was originally coined in the 1940s and referred to produce “without subtraction, addition or alteration”, harvested and eaten fresh, raised without pesticides, herbicides or chemical fertilizers – in other words, both unprocessed and organic.
Whole food in horse products is definitely not the same as organic. If you don’t see the USDA seal of certification, it’s not organic. Non-GMO is not the same thing as organic either, and no guarantee the product does not contain chemicals even far more dangerous than glyphosate.
Whole food is supposed to mean not processed in any way – like eating an apple or peach. Reference might be made to minimum necessary processing. This should include things like peeling a banana to eat it, rinsing dirt off a carrot, or cracking open a nut. However, in one prominent feed that plays the whole-food card, the only actual whole food in it is oats. Everything else has been ground, skinned, pelletized, dried, heat dehydrated (and possibly preserved with sulfur dioxide), dehulled, cleaned, exposed to strong magnetic fields, steamed (split peas), polished, or solvent extracted.
The reality is that very few whole foods will escape rotting inside a feed bag without processing or preservatives. Even drying and grinding leads to loss of some vitamins and fragile fatty acids. What starts out as a whole food loses some critical portions of its nutrition by the time it goes into a bag and really isn’t a whole food any longer.
Whole food supplements have another problem. In addition to not really being whole foods after they are processed into a powder or bar, the levels of nutrients they provide falls far, far short of being helpful. For example, one “multi” type whole food supplement made from fruits, vegetables, nuts (and some most definitely not whole foods like oils, bran, and processed yeast) provides the following amounts of nutrients per daily serving:
- Protein: 6.2 grams versus requirement of 630 grams (500 kg horse at maintenance)
- Calcium: 0.8 grams versus requirement of 20 grams
- Copper: 0.4 mg versus requirement of 100 mg
- Zinc: 1.35 mg versus requirement of 450 mg
Those are only the rock bottom, bare minimum requirements in health. Actual optimal requirements can be much higher.
Are these numbers misleading because nutrients in foods are much more bioavailable? No. That’s a myth. In fact, research has shown that minerals in foods are far less bioavailable than minerals in supplements, including inorganic minerals from rock.
There’s nothing wrong with the ingredients that go into these feeds and supplements, but the suggestion they are superior to other products does not stand up to scrutiny. For example, I would much rather feed processed wheat bran with its high protein, minerals and vitamin-packed wheat germ intact than the whole wheat grain which is loaded with high glycemic index starch/flour. The supplements have nice ingredients and are yummy but they’re treats, not supplements.
As much as I favor whole foods like whole oats, it’s not the answer to optimal nutrition for the management scenario of today’s domesticated horse.
About ECIR Group Inc.
Started in 1999, the ECIR Group is the largest field-trial database for PPID and EMS in the world and provides the latest research, diagnosis, and treatment information, in addition to dietary recommendations for horses with these conditions. Even universities do not and cannot compile and follow long term as many in-depth case histories of PPID/EMS horses as the ECIR Group.
In 2013 the Equine Cushing's and Insulin Resistance Group Inc., an Arizona nonprofit corporation, was approved as a 501(c)3 public charity. Tax deductible contributions and grants support ongoing research, education, and awareness of Equine Cushing's Disease/PPID and EMS.
THE MISSION of the ECIR Group Inc. is to improve the welfare of equines with metabolic disorders via a unique interface between basic research and real-life clinical experience. Prevention of laminitis is the ultimate goal. The ECIR Group serves the scientific community, practicing clinicians, and owners by focusing on investigations most likely to quickly, immediately, and significantly benefit the welfare of the horse.
Contact: Nancy Collins
Picture available upon request
AHP has not verified the factual statements in any message and AHP assumes no responsibility for the contents of, or any damage resulting from, any communication in the Newsgroup. Publication in the Newsgroup is not an endorsement by the organization of any product, person, or policy.